If you’ve ever wondered whether you should grade your Pokémon cards, you’re not alone. Grading is one of the most popular topics in the hobby. Some collectors grade cards to increase their value, while others do it simply to protect and display their favorite cards. However, grading isn’t always the right choice. In this guide, we’ll discuss what grading is, when it makes sense, and how to decide whether a Pokémon card is worth grading.
What Does It Mean to Grade a Card?
Professional grading companies evaluate a card’s condition and assign it a numerical grade, usually on a scale from 1 to 10.
The grading process considers factors such as:
- Centering
- Corners
- Edges
- Surface condition
Once graded, the card is sealed inside a protective plastic holder, often called a slab. For many collectors, grading provides confidence in a card’s authenticity and condition.
Why Do Collectors Grade Cards?
There are several reasons collectors choose to grade cards.
Increase Potential Value
A high-grade card can often sell for significantly more than an ungraded copy. For example, a card that appears to be in excellent condition may receive a high grade such as a PSA 10 or CGC Pristine 10, making it more attractive to collectors and buyers. However, grading does not automatically increase a card’s value. The card must be valuable enough and receive a strong grade to justify the grading fee.
Protect Valuable Cards
Graded cards are sealed inside a hard plastic case that helps protect them from:
- Scratches
- Moisture
- Dust
- Everyday handling
Many collectors grade cards simply for long-term preservation.
Improve Buyer Confidence
If you plan to sell a card in the future, a professional grade can provide reassurance regarding its condition and authenticity. This can make selling easier, especially for higher-value cards.
When Should You Grade a Pokémon Card?
Not every card is worth grading.
Here are a few situations where grading may make sense:
The Card is Valuable
Generally, grading is most worthwhile for cards that already have meaningful value.
Examples may include:
- Rare vintage cards
- Chase cards from modern sets
- Alternate art cards
- Secret rares
- Promotional cards
If a card is only worth a few dollars, grading fees may exceed the card’s value.
The Card Is in Excellent Condition
Even valuable cards may not be worth grading if they have significant wear.
Before submitting a card, inspect it carefully for:
- Whitening on edges
- Corner damage
- Scratches
- Surface dents
- Poor centering
Cards with obvious flaws are unlikely to receive the highest grades.
The Card Has Personal Meaning
Not every grading decision needs to be financial.
Some collectors grade cards because they:
- Pulled the card themselves
- Received it as a gift
- Have a favorite Pokémon
- Want long-term protection
In these situations, sentimental value may matter more than market value.
When You Probably Shouldn’t Grade a Card
There are also situations where grading may not be worth the cost.
Low-Value Cards
Many modern cards can be purchased for less than the cost of grading. Unless the card is exceptionally rare or likely to receive a top grade, grading may not make financial sense.
Cards with Significant Damage
Cards with:
- Creases
- Heavy whitening
- Major scratches
- Water damage
typically receive lower grades. In these cases, grading may not increase the card’s value.
If You Plan to Keep It in a Binder
Some collectors simply enjoy viewing their cards in a binder. If you’re happy storing cards in sleeves and binders, grading may not provide enough additional benefit to justify the expense.
Popular Card Grading Companies
Several companies offer Pokémon card grading services.
PSA
PSA is currently one of the most recognized grading companies in the hobby.
Many collectors prefer PSA because:
- Strong market recognition
- Large population reports
- Strong resale value
CGC
CGC has become increasingly popular among Pokémon collectors.
Collectors often appreciate:
- Consistent grading
- Attractive slabs
- Competitive pricing
Beckett (BGS)
Beckett is known for its subgrades and strict grading standards.
A Beckett Black Label is considered one of the most prestigious grades in the hobby.
If you’re deciding among the most popular grading services, read our comparison of Which Grading Service Is Best for Pokémon Cards?
How Much Does Pokémon Card Grading Cost?
Costs vary depending on:
- Grading company
- Service level
- Card value
- Turnaround time
Some grading companies also charge higher fees for cards with greater declared values. Always review current pricing before submitting cards. Many collectors make the mistake of grading cards that are unlikely to increase in value enough to offset the grading costs.
Questions to Ask Before Grading
Ask Yourself These Questions Before Grading
Before submitting a card for grading, consider:
- Is the card valuable enough to justify the grading fee?
- Does the card appear to be in near-mint or mint condition?
- Am I grading this card for resale or personal enjoyment?
- Would I still be happy owning the card if it received a lower grade than expected?
Answering these questions can help prevent costly grading decisions and set realistic expectations.
Tips Before Sending a Card for Grading
Use Proper Protection
Before shipping:
- Place the card in a penny sleeve
- Use a semi-rigid card holder or an approved submission holder
Inspect the Card Carefully
Check:
- Corners
- Edges
- Surface
- Centering
The better your assessment, the fewer surprises you’ll have when the grade is returned.
Manage Expectations
Many cards that look perfect to the naked eye do not receive a perfect grade. It is also important to remember that grading turnaround times can range from several weeks to several months, depending on the company and service level selected.
Final Thoughts
Grading Pokémon cards can be a great way to protect valuable cards, increase buyer confidence, and potentially improve resale value. However, not every card should be graded.
If you’re still wondering whether to grade your Pokémon cards, consider the card’s value, condition, and your goals as a collector before submitting. For some cards, grading makes perfect sense. For others, a quality penny sleeve and binder may provide all the protection you need.
Ultimately, the best grading decision is one that aligns with your collecting goals, whether you’re building a personal collection, investing in rare cards, or preserving your favorite Pokémon memories.